|
PUBA 660C: Public Budgeting
Spring 2007
Christopher Grandy
506 Saunders Hall
956-7060
grandy@hawaii.edu
Syllabus
Purpose: The purpose of this course is to give you an
overview, with some in-depth analysis, of public budgeting at all
levels (federal, state, and local) of government (non-profit budgeting
not included). You will
become familiar with the common terms and some of the cutting-edge
issues. You will learn how budgeting issues are intimately related to
policy proposals. And you will track the budgetary process for a
particular unit of the Hawaii state government.
Readings:
Books:
(F) Fosythe, Dall W. 2004. Memos to the Governor: An
Introduction to
State Budgeting. Second ed. Updated. Georgetown Univ. Press.
(M) Mikesell, John L. 2007. Fiscal Administration. 7th
edition. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
Articles/Chapters:
Fisher, Ian. 2000. "Somali
Businesses Stunted by Too-Free
Enterprise." New York Times.
August 10, 2000.
Cornia, Gary C., Ray D.
Nelson, and Andrea Wilko. 2004.
"Fiscal Planning, Budgeting, and Rebudgeting Using Revenue
Semaphores." Public
Administration Review. 64(2): 164-179 (March/April).
Conlan, Tim. 2006. "From
Cooperative to Opportunistic
Federalism: Reflections on the Half-Century Anniversary of the
Commission on Intergovernmental Relations." Public Administration Review 66(5):
663-676 (Sep/Oct).
Downs, George W. and Patrick D.
Larkey. 1986. The Search
For Government Efficiency: From Hubris to Helplessness.
Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Chapter 5.
Fox, William. 2006.
"Hawaii's General Excise Tax: Should the Base be Changed?"
2005-2007 Tax Review Commission Report, Appendix C. State of
Hawaii.
Gilmour, John B. and David E.
Lewis. 2006. "Does Performance
Budgeting Work? An Examination of the Office of Management and Budget's
PART Scores." Public Administration
Review. 66(5):
742-752 (Sep/Oct).
Higgs, Robert. 1987. Crisis and Leviathan: Critical
Episodes in the Growth of American Government. New
York: Oxford University Press. Chapter 2.
Hou, Yilin. 2006. "Budgeting
for Fiscal Stability Over the
Business Cycle: A Countercyclical Fiscal Policy and the Multiyear
Perspective on Budgeting." Public
Administration Review. 66(5):
730-741 (Sep/Oct).
Kloha, Philip, Carol S.
Weissert, and Robert Kleine. 2005.
"Developing and Testing a Composite Model to Predict Local Fiscal
Stress." Public Administration Review
65(3): 313-323 (May/June).
Lindert, Peter H. 2004. Growing Public: Social Spending and
Economic Growth Since the Eighteenth Century. Vol I: The
Story. New York: Cambridge University Press. Chapter
12.
Rubin, Marilyn Marks and John R.
Bartle. 2005. "Integrating
Gender into Government Budgets: A New Perspective." Public Administration Review.
65(3): 259-272 (May/June).
Tax Review Commission, State of
Hawaii. Report of the 2005-2007 Tax Review Commission.
Relevant online documents:
Required work:
- Attendance and participation
is important because we meet only weekly and because this may be a
small class. Each week, participants will be expected to attend class
AND to make a posting on the discussion section of our course in WebCT.
The weekly contribution must be posted BEFORE class each week, and may
comment on the readings to be discussed, pick up an issue raised in a
previous class, or discuss related issues found in newspapers or other
periodicals. The purpose of this posting is to encourage you to
actively think about, and apply, the ideas and concepts that we
discuss; and to encourage others to engage your observations and ideas.
The postings need not be long, but they should be substantive in terms
of content.
Because unexpected events happen to all of us, up to two
missed classes may be made up by a substantial posting in the week of
the absence. A third missed class will negatively affect the final
grade in the course. A fourth missed class will result in an Incomplete
or failing grade.
- Project: You will each choose an organizational unit of the
State of
Hawaii to follow during the 2007 Legislative Session. The unit may be
an entire department, a division within the department, or another unit
(chosen in consultation with me). Your general task is to follow the
budgetary issues related to this unit over the course of the semester.
Sources of information include, but are not limited to, legislative
testimony, newspaper (or other news) articles, interviews or
conversations with participants, press releases, and legislative
hearings. I would like you to attend at least one legislative hearing
related to budget issues for the unit you have chosen (fairly
frequently, legislative hearings take place in the evenings).
- On February 9, you will submit your First Project
Report. This is a
short, written report that describes your unit, its mission and/or
goals, its clients, its budgetary status, and the current executive
budget proposal for fiscal year (FY) 2007 and beyond. By “budgetary
status” I mean background information on the number of dollars and
positions in the unit (such as last year’s appropriation and number of
positions). The report should include a discussion of any issues that
seem particularly relevant to the unit and/or its budget. The report
should not exceed 6 pages (double-spaced).
- On April 6, you will submit the Second Project Report.
This will
document what has happened to the budget request since the first
report. What changes have been proposed and made? What has been the
response of the unit and/or department in testimony? What other
information (press releases, news items, etc.) sheds light on the path
of the unit’s budget request and related issues? Please pay attention
to the apparent strategies employed by the players to accomplish their
goals (primarily the unit, but also potentially the department, the
governor, and key legislators). You may want to look over Memo 7 in
Forsythe early in this process.
- On April 27 or May 4, you will make a class
presentation on your
unit and the “final” condition of its budget request (“final” is in
quotation marks because the process may not be complete by this time).
The presentation should include any background information that will be
necessary for your classmates to understand the unit and its issues. To
the extent feasible, you should attempt to incorporate, or link to, the
budgetary concepts/issues that we covered or discussed in class. The
purpose of this presentation is to display your ability to identify and
apply the concepts and ideas to the budget issues for your unit.
On the same day, you will hand in a written reflection piece in which
you review what you have experienced in this project. I would like you
to do this at (at least) two levels:
(1) In thinking about the
budgetary process as applied to your unit, what are the three most
important “lessons” that you learned? How might the unit have been more
effective in pursuing its budgetary goals? What might it have done
differently? What could it do in the future to better position itself?
These are only suggested questions of the kinds of issues that may be
relevant; feel free to add/substitute your own.
(2) With respect to this course project, what worked well? What didn’t?
How might the project be structured in the future to make it a more
effective, or more interesting, learning tool?
Course Grade: Your grade in this course will be assigned as follows:
| Class
discussion (including weekly WebCT
discussion postings) |
15%
|
| First Project
Report |
20%
|
| Second
Project Report |
30%
|
| Final Project
Presentation and reflection piece |
35%
|
Outline/Calendar:
Date
|
Topic
|
Readings marked with
* are optional (but recommended) |
Jan. 12
|
Introduction and Overview
Budget Principles & Concepts
|
M: 1
Fisher
|
Jan. 19
|
Methods/Logic
overview |
M: 2
|
Jan. 26
|
Structures (federal)
|
M: 3 (pp. 79-118)
Budget
System and Concepts* (useful for definitions)
Higgs*
Gilmour and Lewis
|
Feb. 2
|
Structures (state 1)
|
M: 3 (pp. 118-131)
F: 2, 3, 4
Hawaii
Constitution, Article VII
Hawaii
Revised Statutes, Ch. 37 (light skim)
|
Feb. 9
|
Structures (state 2)
|
F: 5, 6, 8
Guest: Huong Bassford, Dept. of Budget & Finance
|
Feb. 16
|
Structures (local)
|
C&C Operating Budget FY2007
(1.8
Mb)
C&C Capital Budget FY2007
(2.1 Mb)
Kloha, Weissert, and
Kleine
|
Feb. 23
|
Capital Budgeting &
Debt
|
M: 6 & 15
|
Mar. 2
|
Government Revenue
|
M: 7 & 11
Guest: Isaac Choy, Chair of 2005-2007Tax Review Commission
Lindert
Tax Review Commission report
|
Mar. 9
|
Taxation: Income Tax
|
M: 8
|
Mar. 16
|
Taxation:
Sales/Consumption Taxes
|
M: 9
Fox
|
Mar. 23
|
Taxation: Property
Taxes
|
M: 10
|
Mar. 30
|
NO CLASS: Spring
Break
|
|
Apr. 6
|
NO CLASS: Holiday
|
|
Apr. 13
|
Budget Reforms
|
M: 5
Downs & Larkey
Rubin, Marks and Bartle
|
Apr. 20
|
Student presentations
|
|
Apr. 27
|
Student presentations
|
|
Date Modified: 02/09/07
|
|